Compare campaigns

Compare campaigns

Read the claims and horizons together. Shared instruments alone do not imply a conflict.

← All campaigns

Energy shock to hardship: the Saudi phase of the Iran war

The Saudi phase of the Iran war transmits to Western households through refining, freight and interest rates — not, so far, through grain and fertilizer. Reviewed on the 2026-09-18 settled close: the distillate and shipping links are fully priced (US retail diesel a record $5.901/gal on 2026-09-08 with crude ~$28/bbl below its 2022 level; ULSD crack $108.02/bbl intraday 2026-09-03; Hormuz transits 4 vessels on 2026-09-14 against a pre-war ~125/day; war-risk cover quoted at 40x normal; 2026 tanker orders more than twice 2025's count, ~$20bn, per Semafor 2026-09-18) while the food link is not (August CPI, released 2026-09-11: food at home 0.0% m/m and +2.2% y/y, decelerating from 2.7%, against energy +16.3% y/y and fuel oil +52.0% y/y; the agriculture fund closed 2026-09-18 at $28.15, RSI 41.4, -2.7% on the week and 0.3% under its 50-day). The testable claim is that hardship in the US and Europe arrives this cycle as fuel, freight and borrowing costs — the Fed hiked 25bp on 2026-09-16, its first hike since 2023, with the 10-year Treasury yield at or above 5% on 2026-09-15, 2026-09-16 and 2026-09-18 and on every observation since 2026-09-23 (5.24% on 2026-09-28, the latest) — and that the food-price link completes only if the September CPI (released 2026-10-14) or a cold European winter against 68.7% storage (2026-09-16) forces it.

Why now
The war moved onto Saudi soil in the week of 2026-09-14: an Iran-backed Iraqi militia drone strike shut the roughly 750-mile East-West pipeline that bypasses Hormuz (CNBC, 2026-09-13/14), Aramco suspended Yanbu loadings and cancelled cargoes as US crude topped $105 (CNBC and Yahoo Finance, 2026-09-15), and Riyadh answered by rerouting exports through Hormuz with prompt ship-to-ship sales, which took crude back toward $100 by 2026-09-17 (Bloomberg and MarketWatch, 2026-09-17). The 2026-09-18 close shows the market's verdict: crude's fund -0.7% on the week at $153.82 (still +17.5% on 30 days), oil services down hard (Schlumberger -8.81%, Halliburton -6.14%), and refiners and tankers vertical (MPC RSI 83.0, CVI 81.4, VLO 80.1, DHT 77.2, FRO 73.9) — a routing and refining problem, not a barrel shortage. The May 2026 frames written for a Hormuz-only war (oil-200-scenario, food-security-cascade, crypto-geopolitics) are history; this is their successor for the energy-to-hardship chain, and its weakest link has a dated test on 2026-10-14.
In scope
The physical chain link by link with a dated receipt at each: crude routing and transit counts, refined-product cracks, freight rates and war-risk insurance, fertilizer and grain prices, official CPI and EU storage prints · US and European consumer transmission measured only on official prints (CPI food at home, energy, airfares; Gas Infrastructure Europe storage; TTF) · The tradable expressions of each link: refiners, crude and product tankers, fertilizer and grain funds, and the fuel-cost casualties in cruise and airline names · An explicit standing statement of which links the tape already prices and which it does not
Out of scope
Forecasting the war's political end, a ceasefire date, or the outcome of the UN Gulf meetings · Treating headline intensity or a single-session price move as evidence that a link has transmitted · Reopening the May 2026 Hormuz-only frames on their old numeric triggers · Humanitarian claims about Europe or the US without a dated September-2026-or-later appeal, household bill or relief measure on file · Pre-revenue, leveraged, inverse or single-stock-derivative expressions of any link
Expected horizon
Weeks to two quarters. Freight and insurance costs land on Western shelves with a one-to-two-quarter lag, so the case is graded through the 2026-27 northern winter and closed or promoted by the March 2027 CPI cycle.
What supports it
A dated official print or operator notice at each link — BLS CPI, Gas Infrastructure Europe storage, Aramco loading or pipeline notices, published Hormuz transit counts · The cost appearing in realized company numbers rather than only in the commodity: refiner crack capture, tanker realized day rates, a shipper or grocer naming fuel surcharge in a filing · A September-2026-or-later humanitarian, relief or household-energy receipt specific to Europe or the US would complete the case's weakest link; none exists on file as of 2026-09-18
What would break it
The September (2026-10-14) and October CPI prints leave food at home flat-to-negative while energy decelerates — the chain stops at freight and the food link never completes · Saudi restores East-West pipeline flows and Hormuz transits normalize, taking cracks and tanker rates back toward pre-September levels: refiner RSI back under 50 and FRO, DHT, INSW and STNG losing their 50-day averages · EU storage reaches or closely approaches the 90% target by 2026-12-01 on a mild winter and TTF falls back below the January 2023 level · The hardship link stays undocumented into Q1 2027 — no dated European or US household energy-bill, relief or food-assistance receipt appears — in which case the humanitarian framing was the wrong lens and the case is an energy-to-freight-to-rates case only

Next review 2026-11-10 · The October CPI release on 2026-11-10 is the second dated test; the September print (2026-10-14) left it undecided: food at home fell 0.1% while energy rose 5.2% (seasonally adjusted), so neither branch held. Food at home turning positive on the month while energy stays elevated confirms transmission into the food link and promotes the case; a second flat-to-negative food-at-home month against decelerating energy fails that link and reduces the case to energy-to-freight-to-rates. If food at home is flat-to-negative again while energy stays elevated, the review restates the 'decelerating energy' qualifier for the user's decision rather than treating either branch as met. Review earlier on an official EU storage or TTF break, a pipeline restart or Hormuz transit normalization notice, or the first dated European or US household-energy relief measure.

Research ideas

All 0 ideas →

Issued calls · returns compare the symbol with SPY after 30 and 90 days. Positive excess supports a BUY; negative excess supports TRIM or SELL. WAIT and research ideas have no score. These are call outcomes, not a campaign return.

Entry and invalidationHorizon / review30 days90 days
DBAWAIT2026-09-18 · openOriginal call

DBA back over its 50-day with RSI above 50 (Sept 18 close $28.15, RSI 41.4, 0.3% under the 50-day), confirmed by a positive food-at-home month in the September CPI on Oct 14

Invalidation: DBA loses its 200-day (4.1% below Friday's close) or the Oct 14 print leaves food at home flat-to-negative again

Not recordedReview 2026-10-14
Not gradedNot graded

Energy disruption: physical flows and exporter economics

Persistent physical energy-supply disruption can improve selected exporters’ realized economics until flows recover; oil, gas and LNG transmission must be proved separately.

Why now
EIA’s August assessment documents disruption and a conditional recovery path. The September outlook is the next scheduled checkpoint; current company transmission remains incomplete.
In scope
Verified oil and gas flows, inventories, freight and realized company economics · The energy-flow branch of the former Gulf scenario
Out of scope
Predicting the political end of the war · Treating public attention or price moves as proof of lost supply · Qatar helium/fabrication contagion without direct evidence · Assuming refiners, producers and services benefit equally
Expected horizon
Weeks to 6 months; reassess at each material flow change and monthly EIA outlook.
What supports it
Official or operator evidence confirms continuing lost supply or costly rerouting · Reported volumes and realized margins identify actual beneficiaries
What would break it
Flows normalize and inventories rebuild without sustained exporter margin advantage · Demand destruction or costs eliminate the proposed beneficiary economics
Curated instrumentsXOMCVXCOPEOGLNGTRGP

Next review 2026-10-30 · Read ExxonMobil and Chevron third-quarter results (scheduled 2026-10-30, provider estimates) and Cheniere (2026-10-29) for realized oil, gas and LNG prices and upstream margins against the pre-war base; ConocoPhillips, EOG and Targa follow on 2026-11-05. Before then, capture the October Short-Term Energy Outlook as a source and read it against the September outlook (released 2026-10-06 per news coverage, but only a one-paragraph summary is on file), read the bodies of ExxonMobil's 8-K (2026-09-25) and Chevron's 8-K (2026-10-05), and capture the late-September flow reports (Kpler near 80% of pre-war, CNBC crude exports at pre-war, Fortune October 4) so they can be linked. Earlier on an official Hormuz closure or re-escalation notice, tanker attacks that reverse the flow recovery, or a change to the G7 stock release. As of the 2026-10-16 review: the re-escalation and the attack half of the tanker condition have fired on named-wire reports (2026-10-06 to 2026-10-16), so further attack reports or price moves alone are not a trigger; the reversal half has only secondary support, and a primary or named-wire Hormuz crude flow count after 2026-10-08 completes it; the stock-release clause did not fire, since the International Energy Agency decisions of 2026-10-07 and 2026-10-15 carry out the G7 and partners' 2026-10-02 release of up to 100 million barrels, and added volume beyond it, or a halt, is the change. Official crude flows at pre-war with inventories rebuilding and no third-quarter realized-margin advantage complete the failure condition for the crude branch; gas and LNG are judged separately.

Research ideas

All 0 ideas →

Issued calls · returns compare the symbol with SPY after 30 and 90 days. Positive excess supports a BUY; negative excess supports TRIM or SELL. WAIT and research ideas have no score. These are call outcomes, not a campaign return.

Entry and invalidationHorizon / review30 days90 days
CVXWAIT2026-07-31 · openOriginal call

strongest RSI in the upstream cohort (67.2) — hold above the 20-day (~$185.34) to stay constructive

Invalidation: loses the 50-day (~$182.75)

Not recordedReview 2026-09-11
Not gradedNot graded
GLDWAIT2026-07-31 · resolved:closedOriginal call

this is a signal to watch, not a trade — a reclaim of the 20-day (~$373.15) would be the first sign of the safe-haven bid this week's tape didn't produce

Invalidation: n/a — continued weakness alongside a weakening dollar (UUP) is the non-confirmation already in the data

Not recordedReview 2026-09-11
Not gradedNot graded
HALEAVOID2026-07-31 · openOriginal call

not a trend-hold candidate yet — wait for a base and a reclaim of the 50-day (~$36.18) before treating any bounce as more than a dead-cat pop

Invalidation: n/a — the condition to flip constructive is the 50-day reclaim above; a fresh 52-week low confirms the derate instead

Not recordedReview 2026-09-11
Not gradedNot graded
PSXWAIT2026-07-31 · resolved:closedOriginal call

RSI is a hair under overbought (69.7) — wait for a pullback to the 20-day (~$200.76) rather than chasing the extended print

Invalidation: loses the 50-day (~$185.74), turning the refining leg's leadership into a rollover

Not recordedReview 2026-09-11
Not gradedNot graded
USOWAIT2026-07-31 · openOriginal call

the -5.5% weekly pullback holds above the 20-day (~$121.96) — a normal pullback inside a strong-up trend, not a reversal

Invalidation: closes back below the 20-day and takes out the $126.55 support shelf

Not recordedReview 2026-09-11
Not gradedNot graded
VLOWAIT2026-07-31 · resolved:closedOriginal call

same setup as PSX — a pullback to the 20-day (~$295.63); note this row is one session stale (2026-07-30 close), confirm Friday's print before acting

Invalidation: loses the 50-day (~$269.30)

Not recordedReview 2026-09-11
Not gradedNot graded
CLMTPASS2026-07-18 · openOriginal call

RSI 83 on 2.7x volume, +165% in a year — parabolic-chaser material, not trend-hold; reopen only on a first pullback that holds $36.99 (20-day) with volume drying up

Invalidation: n/a — not owned; wrong if $36.99 holds on the first test and the trend resumes

Not recordedReview 2026-09-04
Not gradedNot graded
DKPASS2026-07-18 · openOriginal call

reopen if it builds a multi-week base above the 20-day ($52.58) and resumes — a small refiner +53% in 30 days and +20% over its own 20-day is the gap, not the setup

Invalidation: n/a — not owned; the pass is wrong (and will be scored wrong) if that base forms and the resumption runs without us

Not recordedReview 2026-09-04
Not gradedNot graded
MPCWAIT2026-07-18 · openOriginal call

the lane's quality large-cap; interest begins on the first pullback that HOLDS the 20-day ($272.00) after the Aug 4 print validates Q2 margins — at +15% above the 20-day, buying today buys the gap

Invalidation: a close below the 50-day ($261.52) breaks the momentum regime and the lane read resets

Not recordedReview 2026-08-21
Not gradedNot graded
PSXWAIT2026-07-18 · resolved:closedOriginal call

the diversified laggard of the three (+70% on the year, midstream/chem mix dilutes the crack exposure); first 20-day hold ($181.86) after the Aug 5 print

Invalidation: a close below the 50-day ($178.65) — barely below the 20-day, so this one resolves fast

Not recordedReview 2026-08-21
Not gradedNot graded
VLOWAIT2026-07-18 · resolved:closedOriginal call

best 12-month tape of the pure refiners (+117%); same frame — first 20-day hold ($271.29) after the Jul 30 print, the earliest verification event in the lane

Invalidation: a close below the 50-day ($257.97) breaks the momentum regime

Not recordedReview 2026-08-21
Not gradedNot graded

Shared evidence

7 sources linked to both campaigns. Each interpretation belongs to its own claim.

Makai Research - VLCC owners slow-steam in ballast despite $600k-$1m a day earnings, propping up the freight spike

Energy shock to hardship: the Saudi phase of the Iran war

context · No interpretation recorded

Energy disruption: physical flows and exporter economics

context · No interpretation recorded

Read source →
Semafor — Houthis strike Riyadh a second day as Iran steps up Hormuz attacks

Energy shock to hardship: the Saudi phase of the Iran war

context · No interpretation recorded

Energy disruption: physical flows and exporter economics

context · Documents the October re-escalation against both the Gulf's largest exporter and its main shipping lane: Houthi missiles hit Riyadh a second day while Iran stepped up attacks on ships in Hormuz (Semafor, October 8). Later named-wire reports extend it: a container ship sunk on October 14 (Bloomberg, citing Singapore's port authority), two cargo ships sunk near Hormuz (Semafor, October 15), and escalated attacks the week Brent touched $110 (CNBC, Bloomberg, October 16). This is attack evidence, not a flow count: it completes the attack half of the case's tanker condition but not the reversal half, and the case escalates only on physical evidence.

Read source →
Frontier Map — Europe paid 8.6 times the US gas price in September as Hormuz cut Qatar's LNG exports

Energy shock to hardship: the Saudi phase of the Iran war

context · No interpretation recorded

Energy disruption: physical flows and exporter economics

context · No interpretation recorded

Read source →
Eric Nuttall — exports recover to a 14.3MM bbl/d 7-day average but are still ~4MM short, and OilX has Mideast output down 6.6MM bbl/d

Energy shock to hardship: the Saudi phase of the Iran war

context · No interpretation recorded

Energy disruption: physical flows and exporter economics

challenges · Recovery evidence against the persistence premise, with the residual gap kept in view. Eric Nuttall's September 30 count puts total Gulf exports at a 14.3 million barrel-a-day seven-day average, still about 4 million short and costing roughly $25–30 a barrel to achieve, with OilX showing Middle East output down 6.6 million barrels a day; the same day a JPMorgan read relayed from a paywalled Bloomberg headline put flows at 98% of pre-war. Alongside CNBC's September 30 report of Hormuz crude exports back at pre-war levels, it moves the crude branch toward the case's own exit, flows recovering, while the shortfall and rerouting cost keep that branch open. It is flow evidence, not company margins.

Read source →
Tanker orders double as the Iran war redraws crude routes (Semafor, Sept 18) — article

Energy shock to hardship: the Saudi phase of the Iran war

supports · The freight link's strongest receipt. Owners ordering more than twice 2025's tanker count (~$20bn, the largest run in at least 25 years) with lease rates up roughly tenfold year over year means the ton-mile shock is being capitalised, not traded — durable enough to build hulls against. It supports the routing-not-shortage reading and simultaneously names the thing that ends the tanker leg: newbuild supply on a two-to-three-year delivery lag, against FRO/DHT/INSW/STNG at RSI 69-77 on the 2026-09-18 close.

Energy disruption: physical flows and exporter economics

supports · Physical-flow evidence for the disruption-and-rerouting branch: with Saudi Arabia's East-West pipeline shut, buyers are pulling crude from the Americas on longer voyages, shipowners have ordered more than twice 2025's tanker count (~$20bn) and daily lease rates are up roughly tenfold year over year. Rerouting, not lost supply, is what the freight market is capitalising — consistent with the September EIA outlook's gradual-recovery path. It is still route and rate evidence, not company-level realized-margin proof, so it supports the case without promoting it.

Read source →
EU gas storage at 68.7 percent against an 88 percent five-year norm; 90 percent target by December 1 looks out of reach (energynews.pro, Sept 17) — article

Energy shock to hardship: the Saudi phase of the Iran war

supports · The European household link's only dated September receipt, and it is on storage rather than on bills: 68.7% full on 2026-09-16 against an 88% five-year norm, roughly 19 points short of the 90% target due 2026-12-01, with TTF at 79.38 EUR/MWh. It establishes the physical setup for a European hardship winter without establishing that hardship — the distinction the case is built to hold.

Energy disruption: physical flows and exporter economics

supports · The gas branch is still disrupted while crude recovers: EU storage stood at 68.7% on September 16 against an 88% five-year average, with the 90% December 1 target out of reach and Qatari and Emirati LNG cut by the Hormuz disruption while Asian buyers compete for cargoes. That supports continued demand for LNG supplied from outside the Gulf. Transmission into US exporters' realized prices and margins is unverified until third-quarter reports.

Read source →
War-risk cover at 40 times normal; Hormuz down to 4 ships a day; box rates above 10,000 dollars (Aju Press, Sept 15) — article

Energy shock to hardship: the Saudi phase of the Iran war

supports · The cost receipt between the barrel and the shelf: Hormuz transits at 4 vessels on 2026-09-14 against a pre-war ~125/day, war-risk cover at 40x normal (a VLCC's premium running from $250,000 toward $10m), Shanghai-New York at $9,726/FEU and Bab el-Mandeb at 23% of August 2023 capacity. This is the mechanism by which the shock reaches Western shelves, and the stated one-to-two-quarter lag is why the food link can still be flat in the August CPI without falsifying the case.

Energy disruption: physical flows and exporter economics

supports · The transit evidence the standing review condition asks for: Hormuz transits at 4 vessels on 2026-09-14 against a pre-war ~125/day, war-risk cover quoted at 40x normal, Bab el-Mandeb at 23% of August 2023 capacity. Read alongside Saudi Arabia's pivot to Hormuz exports and ship-to-ship transfers after the 2026-09-13/14 pipeline strike (Bloomberg and MarketWatch, 2026-09-17, captured but not carried as a separate event), it is an official-grade transit reading that triggers an early look at this case rather than waiting for the October outlook.

Read source →